diff --git a/src/ui/pokedex-ui-handler.ts b/src/ui/pokedex-ui-handler.ts
index 95a240731a3..c2e3731cf0c 100644
--- a/src/ui/pokedex-ui-handler.ts
+++ b/src/ui/pokedex-ui-handler.ts
@@ -1314,13 +1314,18 @@ export default class PokedexUiHandler extends MessageUiHandler {
       });
 
       // Cost Reduction Filter
-      const isCostReduced = starterData.valueReduction > 0;
+      const isCostReducedByOne = starterData.valueReduction === 1;
+      const isCostReducedByTwo = starterData.valueReduction === 2;
       const isCostReductionUnlockable = this.isValueReductionAvailable(container.species.speciesId);
       const fitsCostReduction = this.filterBar.getVals(DropDownColumn.UNLOCKS).some(unlocks => {
         if (unlocks.val === "COST_REDUCTION" && unlocks.state === DropDownState.ON) {
-          return isCostReduced;
+          return isCostReducedByOne || isCostReducedByTwo;
+        } else if (unlocks.val === "COST_REDUCTION" && unlocks.state === DropDownState.ONE) {
+          return isCostReducedByOne;
+        } else if (unlocks.val === "COST_REDUCTION" && unlocks.state === DropDownState.TWO) {
+          return isCostReducedByTwo;
         } else if (unlocks.val === "COST_REDUCTION" && unlocks.state === DropDownState.EXCLUDE) {
-          return isStarterProgressable && !isCostReduced;
+          return isStarterProgressable && !(isCostReducedByOne || isCostReducedByTwo);
         } else if (unlocks.val === "COST_REDUCTION" && unlocks.state === DropDownState.UNLOCKABLE) {
           return isCostReductionUnlockable;
         } else if (unlocks.val === "COST_REDUCTION" && unlocks.state === DropDownState.OFF) {